Auto Insurance Deductibles Explained: How to Choose the Right Amount

Your deductible is one of the most important — yet most misunderstood — parts of your auto insurance policy. Choosing the right deductible can mean the difference between an affordable premium and one that strains your budget, or between a manageable out-of-pocket expense after an accident and a financial hardship.

In this guide, we'll explain exactly what a deductible is, compare common deductible levels ($250, $500, and $1,000), show you how your deductible affects your premium, and help you decide which amount is right for your situation.

What Is an Auto Insurance Deductible?

A deductible is the amount of money you pay out of your own pocket before your insurance company pays for a covered claim. For example, if you have a $500 deductible and you're in an accident that causes $3,000 in damage to your car, you pay the first $500 and your insurer pays the remaining $2,500.

Deductibles apply to two types of coverage on your auto insurance policy:

Collision coverage: Pays for damage to your car from a collision with another vehicle or object, regardless of fault.
Comprehensive coverage: Pays for damage from non-collision events like theft, vandalism, hail, flooding, falling objects, or animal strikes.

You can typically set different deductible amounts for collision and comprehensive coverage. Liability coverage (which pays for damage you cause to others) does not have a deductible.

How the Deductible Works in Practice

Let's say you rear-end another car and your vehicle needs $4,000 in repairs. Here's how different deductible levels affect what you pay:

$250 deductible: You pay $250, insurer pays $3,750
$500 deductible: You pay $500, insurer pays $3,500
$1,000 deductible: You pay $1,000, insurer pays $3,000

Important: if the damage is less than your deductible, your insurance doesn't pay anything. With a $1,000 deductible, a $800 fender bender is entirely out of your pocket.

$250 vs $500 vs $1,000 Deductible: A Detailed Comparison

The three most common deductible levels are $250, $500, and $1,000. Here's how they compare across several important factors:

Premium Differences

The relationship between deductibles and premiums is straightforward: higher deductible = lower premium. Here's a typical example using an average full coverage policy:

$250 deductible: ~$1,800/year premium
$500 deductible: ~$1,600/year premium (save ~$200/year)
$1,000 deductible: ~$1,350/year premium (save ~$450/year vs $250 deductible)

The exact savings vary by insurer, location, vehicle, and driver profile, but these proportions are typical. Moving from a $250 to a $1,000 deductible commonly saves 15-40% on collision and comprehensive premiums.

Out-of-Pocket Risk

The flip side of lower premiums is higher out-of-pocket costs when you file a claim:

$250 deductible: Low out-of-pocket cost per claim. Best if you can't easily absorb unexpected expenses.
$500 deductible: Moderate out-of-pocket cost. The most popular choice — a good balance between premium savings and manageable risk.
$1,000 deductible: Higher out-of-pocket cost, but significantly lower premiums. Best for drivers with healthy emergency funds.

Break-Even Analysis

One useful way to decide is to calculate the "break-even point" — how many claim-free years it takes for the premium savings to exceed the additional out-of-pocket risk:

Example: $500 vs $1,000 deductible

Additional risk per claim: $500 ($1,000 - $500)
Annual premium savings: ~$250
Break-even: 2 years

If you go more than 2 years without a collision or comprehensive claim, the $1,000 deductible saves you money overall. Given that the average driver files a claim only once every 10-18 years, a higher deductible is statistically the better financial choice for most people.

How Your Deductible Affects Your Premium

Your deductible only affects the portions of your premium related to collision and comprehensive coverage. It has no impact on your liability, uninsured motorist, or medical payments coverage costs.

The percentage savings from raising your deductible varies by insurer, but here are typical ranges:

$250 → $500: 8-15% reduction in collision/comprehensive premium
$500 → $1,000: 15-25% reduction in collision/comprehensive premium
$250 → $1,000: 25-40% reduction in collision/comprehensive premium

Since collision and comprehensive typically make up 30-50% of your total auto insurance premium, the overall policy savings from raising your deductible might be 10-20% of your total bill.

When to Choose a High Deductible ($1,000+)

A higher deductible makes sense if:

You have an emergency fund: If you can comfortably pay $1,000 out of pocket without financial stress, the premium savings are worth it.
You're a safe driver: If you rarely file claims (most drivers don't), you'll pocket the premium savings year after year.
Your car has a lower value: For older cars worth less than $5,000-$10,000, a high deductible makes the math even more favorable. (You might even consider dropping collision/comprehensive entirely.)
You want the lowest possible premium: If you're focused on minimizing monthly costs — perhaps because you're a new driver or have bad credit — a higher deductible is one of the most effective levers.

When to Choose a Low Deductible ($250-$500)

A lower deductible makes sense if:

You don't have savings to cover a large expense: If $1,000 out of pocket would be a hardship, a lower deductible provides peace of mind.
You drive a lot: More time on the road means more exposure to accidents, making a lower deductible more practical.
You live in a high-risk area: If your area has high rates of theft, vandalism, or severe weather, you may file comprehensive claims more frequently.
You have a new or expensive car: Repairs on newer vehicles cost more, and a lower deductible protects you from larger bills.
Your lender requires it: Some auto loan and lease agreements mandate a maximum deductible (often $500 or $1,000).

Can You Have Different Deductibles for Collision and Comprehensive?

Yes, and this is a smart strategy many drivers overlook. You can set a higher deductible for collision (since collision claims tend to be larger, making the deductible a smaller percentage of the total) and a lower deductible for comprehensive (since comprehensive claims like windshield damage or minor theft can be closer to the deductible amount).

For example, you might choose a $1,000 collision deductible and a $250 comprehensive deductible. This saves money on the more expensive collision portion of your premium while keeping comprehensive claims affordable.

Tips for Choosing the Right Deductible

Check your emergency fund. Your deductible should never exceed what you can comfortably pay in an emergency.
Calculate the break-even point. Compare the annual premium savings against the additional out-of-pocket risk to see how many claim-free years it takes to come out ahead.
Consider your driving habits. Safe drivers with short commutes benefit more from higher deductibles.
Factor in your vehicle's value. It doesn't make sense to carry comprehensive/collision with a $250 deductible on a car worth $3,000. The premiums may approach the car's value over time.
Get quotes at multiple deductible levels. When you compare quotes, ask for pricing at $250, $500, and $1,000 deductibles so you can see the exact savings and make an informed decision.
Review annually. As your car ages and depreciates, it may make sense to increase your deductible or drop collision/comprehensive altogether. Check out our guide on 7 ways to lower your auto insurance premium for more strategies.

The Bottom Line

There's no universally "correct" deductible — the right choice depends on your financial situation, driving habits, vehicle value, and risk tolerance. For most drivers, a $500 deductible offers the best balance of premium savings and manageable out-of-pocket risk. If you have a solid emergency fund, bumping up to $1,000 can save you $200-$450+ per year in premium costs.

Whatever you choose, make sure you're not just picking a deductible in isolation. The best approach is to compare full policy quotes at different deductible levels so you can see exactly what each option costs — both in premiums and potential out-of-pocket expenses.

Related articles: